"Poked full of holes" is an idiomatic expression used to describe something or someone that has been subjected to intense scrutiny that has resulted in uncovering numerous flaws, inaccuracies, inconsistencies, or weaknesses in their argument, theory, statement, or overall credibility. It implies that the subject has been thoroughly examined, analyzed, or investigated, leaving no room for doubt or questions about its reliability or solidity.
The phrase originates from the verb "poke," which means to prod, jab, or thrust forcefully, often with a pointed object. By using the expression "poked full of holes," it suggests the act of piercing or puncturing something repeatedly until it is riddled with openings or vulnerabilities.
When applied metaphorically, it indicates that the subject in question has been subjected to relentless criticism, questioning, or skepticism, leading to the discovery of numerous flaws and shortcomings. It implies that the subject's initial claims, arguments, or explanations lacked a substantial foundation or were easily invalidated.
This idiomatic expression is frequently used in contexts related to debates, investigative work, critical analysis, or scientific research where the primary goal is to expose weaknesses, falsehoods, or inconsistencies in arguments, theories, or statements. It conveys the idea that the subject has undergone a thorough examination that has left it significantly weakened, discredited, or lacking in credibility.
